#4261 - Change whitelist/blacklist terminology

Identifier #4261
Issue type Feature request or suggestion
Title Change whitelist/blacklist terminology
Status Completed
Tags

Roadmap: v11 (custom)

Handling member Chris Graham
Addon core
Description Generally in society there is a sense for 'white' being good and 'black'/'dark' being bad.

Examples:
- Whitelist vs Blacklist (the issue being discussed here)
- Black magic
- Black arts / Dark arts
- Black humour / Dark humour
- Black/white thinking

Brains are association-making machines, and they work on both subconscious and conscious levels. If people keep hearing black as bad, they will generalise that on a subconscious level, which may contribute to racism. I know it may sound a bit silly to some, but I think it is actually accurate if you understand human psychology.

Actually I've thought this was a problem for years, and obviously it is difficult/disruptive to change a language and a society to remove negative associations that are deeply embedded. But we can make a start. I hadn't even thought about blacklist/whitelist being problematic specifically as it's so ingrained, but other projects have started using exclusion-list/inclusion-list, which actually is clearer anyway, so making this change really is dealing with low-hanging fruit.
Steps to reproduce

Additional information There is also master/slave terminology, which we reference only slightly. This is a different kind of problem to white/black - it normalises what is a racially-charged term that should really only be used in the sense of discussion historic inequities. Drupal changed it years ago https://www.drupal.org/project/drupal/issues/2275877.
However, I do think this is problematic to change as it's probably built into the SQL spec, and the DB vendors are the ones who really need to change it. If downstream changes it inconsistently then it will just confuse everybody. IMO it's best to focus activist energy there, then downstream can follow.

If there is other terminology we should change please bring it up.
Funded? No
The system will post a comment when this issue is modified (e.g., status changes). To be notified of this, click "Enable comment notifications".

Rating

Unrated